I have no idea how Dick's movies "work" in Hollywood. Sometime the critics absolutely love them (Minority Report) or really hate them (Imposter). I imagine that the closer the work stay to Dick's original, the less they like it. Minority Report strays quite a bit and then goes off on it's own at the halfway mark. They love that movie. Total Recall really has nothing to do with the book and that's sitting at a 79% on RT. I haven't seen Imposter, so I can't say whether this theory holds validity. I'm just throwing it out there as a way to possibly rationalize the critical treatment of PKD films.

Bookmarks